The Thailand equation related to MBD7 from 29 April this year. 

  

  Homepage         Disclaimer to these pages        Part XXXV        Part XXXVI      Index to birth of Kweb

 

  
Back to Part 36

 

Extra text to 24 August
Posted 26 August 2004

Finally I will write a few words upon the Thailand equation that suddenly erupted a few days before Military Bloody Day number seven (MBD7 was on 29 April this year so already four months back.)

Lots of people and lots of Media outlets stumbled upon the big 'Why?' and could not answer it, almost all who try to answer that 'Why?' question say that it is just unknown why those attacks were staged. I think I know a few bits and pieces of the answer and I felt saddened and thought to myself 'May be I should have formulated my enthusiasm of the previous attacks slightly different'.

But there is also contradiction within me, because who stole those 380 automatic weapons from barracks earlier this year? (See end of the text below). Most of the TR19 football team & the 89 other operatives did only have large knifes and little gun power. Or were those automatic weapons indeed stolen by operatives but is there no good 'Iraqi alike' cell structure at the scene in Thailand? I do not know.

To the Thai operatives I can say that I think I understand the emotional part of the 'Why?' question, I felt devastated. But I understood that part, thanks for the enthusiasm. Thanks, thanks a lot. It looks like you believe hefty in me, may be a bit too hefty...
Furthermore my deepest condolences to the families left behind, I hope that in a few years time the suffering will be less deep. That is what I hope.

You know my dear readers, when during attacks five or ten operatives lose their lives at this point in time I can live with that. It is not that I just shrug my shoulders but I can stand it, it is no fun but sometimes it is just needed (from pure military considerations). But when I am under the impression that over one hundred give their lives just to help this story than I am devastated too. That is one of the reasons that I waited so long to write this finally down.

But there is another far more important reason I waited so long to write this, I just do not want to make accusations that are baseless and I just took the time I needed to think it over and over again. What is the fact of matter?

Well it did not skip my attention that according to Thai officials the operatives were all drugged (that was given as some reason for their behavior). But in those days US generals said the same upon Fallujah operatives (they said that the Fallujah drug users had to be delivered...).
Again I do not want to make baseless accusations but it could very well be that there was also some American anti-drugs agitation at the scene.
This is what I still think after four months, that there was American agitation involved and that this agitation was one of the reasons that so many were simply killed in cold blood.

May I ask my readers to email this file a few times to those Thailand officials who might need it? Especially the so called 'secret services'. And more precise it would be good if those officials get the next message:

---My dear Thai officials, I do not know why you were so greedy to kill. The official reason that national security was at stake was crap, national security is not at stake via some knifes. Therefore I will speak softly to you and kindly remind you at the fact that it is in the ways of this long and ongoing story that a 'Bali solution' will not be there in Thailand.
You know how vulnerable you are on that point, but Thailand is a poor but proud country and I would surely regret a 'Bali solution' to your behavior.
After having said that I hope you will look at the problems of the Muslim minority in a serious way, you don't have to throw around millions of money but if indeed the Muslims are discriminated against you must address those problems.---

 

But the Thailand government must understand for sure that in case I find out in some future that indeed there was American agitation at the scene that some form of hefty punishment might be wise. I am not easy going on that part, the Americans are darn good in exporting death and violence and in case you listened to them and got fooled by them you need some hefty punishment. Let that be clear.

 

At the end of these writing that took me so long to write you can read just some Media report. This report is not chosen with for some kind of reason, it was just the first one I came along on Sunday 25 July (and saved all these weeks on my desktop browser). Read it:       

Muslim rebels light fuse in Thailand

Jason Burke reports from Su So, Thailand, whose football team died in an ugly little war waged between Islamic militants and the police and fuelled by religious, ethnic and economic rivalries  

Colonel Chamlong looks out at the rain and smiles. In front of him are 42 men sitting in ranks. Washed and changed after clambering over a muddy assault course, they are now preparing to be lectured on their nation's culture, history and religion. 

But they are not soldiers. They are being detained as suspected militants who have launched a guerrilla campaign in Thailand aimed, as far as anyone can tell, at securing the independence of the three Muslim-dominated provinces on the country's southern border. 'They are misguided men. We want to change their minds,' Chamlong, 51, says. 

The colonel runs a benign boot camp. It is the first of its kind - and the first shown to a Western journalist - in Thailand. How many of the men there are genuine militants is unclear, as all claim to have been unfairly accused. 'A rival told the authorities I had accepted an invitation to join the guerrillas by a man in my village. But I refused,' said Abdul Halim, 18. Others did not refuse. 

Fifty miles from the boot camp by the coast is Su So. The village, set on a ridge surrounded by forest, is dominated by the football ground's concrete grandstand. But few play football in Su So any more. The best side in the village was TR Sports, and all 19 of its players died when they launched a dawn attack on a police post in a nearby town on 28 April. 

The men had machetes and knives, the police M-16s. The team's only survivor was the coach, Pittaiya. His brother, Kamaruddin, top scorer and captain, was killed. 'He was a normal man, a nice man, very quiet,' Pittaiya said last week. 'They were all normal men. I still can't understand how this happened.'

On the day TR Sports was wiped out, 89 other local men also died in a series of attacks on police or army positions. 

There are no clear explanations why more than 100 poorly armed villagers launched themselves against automatic weapons. Some blame religion, others 'outside influences' that convinced the men they were invulnerable. But what is clear is that the attack was part of a wider pattern that has brought the vicious little conflict in the south of Thailand, which has claimed 300 lives already this year, to a new level of intensity. 

Last week two policemen, a school bus driver, a railway official and two village administrators were shot dead. One was Sawan Khaosee, who worked in Su So. When The Observer visited the village office, a few hundred yards from the football stadium, Khaosee's desk remained piled with the papers he had been working on in the hours before his death. Khaosee was a Buddhist, like nearly 95 per cent of Thais. The villagers of Su So, like most of the people in the three provinces where the violence has been concentrated, are Muslim.The fighting that has surged there is often, by outsiders at least, said to be based in religion. 

Islam is a strong element. Ever since the Sultanate of Pattani, a local Islamic kingdom, was annexed by an expansionist Buddhist monarchy more than a century ago, some have fought central rule and called for a separate Islamic state. Revolts in the 1970s and early 1980s were put down with great brutality. 

The most recent violence also has a strong religious flavour. On the day that TR Sports died, another group of men attacked a police post on the outskirts of the town of Pattani after praying at a historic mosque near by. According to Niseng Nilaeh, an eyewitness, the leader called on local people to join the battle to 'sacrifice themselves for God'. Later the police found a 30-page tract arguing that it was a religious obligation for Muslims to fight for the 'lost land' of the Pattani sultanate. 

Religious radicalism has been growing in the south for several years. More conservative, intolerant styles of worship have been imported from the Middle East. Certainly, many of the TR Sports players had been educated in government-registered religious schools and at least two ran their own Islamic study groups. Some had studied in the 200 new medressas -independent Islamic colleges devoted purely to religion - that have sprung up in the past decade. There are some links to a Saudi-funded hardline religious college. 

According to Rawsedee Lertariyapongkul, the president of the Association of Thai Muslim Youth, world events may have angered the footballers. 'People see what is happening in Palestine and Iraq and Kashmir and feel that Muslims are being treated very badly everywhere. They want to fight for justice,' he said. 

But there is no real evidence of any link between the separatists and al-Qaeda or its local affiliates. And for every one of the TR Sports team who appeared devout, there are others who were not. The youngest in the side, 18-year-old Samit Suthonehh, had left a religious school three months earlier because he didn't like it. Four others had just completed their compulsory military service. 

Nor did the players ever show any interest in, or knowledge of, international affairs. There is no satellite dish in Su So. 'The guys were never interested in religion or politics,' said Pittaiya. 'They just liked to play football. All their favourite players were from Brazil or England.' 

Many say the problem is ethnic.The southern provinces are mainly Malay, not Thai.The assailants who decapitated a Buddhist monk in May left a note saying: 'If you continue to arrest innocent Muslims, we will kill innocent Buddhists.' But those who wounded two policemen last week threatened to 'kill innocent Thais' if 'innocent Malays' were harmed. 'That demonstrates how confused these issues are,' said one Thai intelligence expert. 

Others point to socio economic factors. Thailand's economic growth has left the southern provinces trailing. Su So's village elders complain of a lack of electricity, public transport and water pumps. The government has launched major development plans - in Su So there is scheme helping women to stitch clothes for export - but many locals still feel they are treated as second-class citizens.The police are almost entirely Buddhist Thais and abuse human rights. Alleged activists, including a human rights lawyer, frequently 'disappear'. Witnesses, who did not want to be named, said that the young men of TR Sports were executed after surrendering. The 32 men attacked in Pattani appear to have been killed in cold blood. 

The final complicating factor in the south is crime. Smuggling - of arms, people and drugs - generates hundreds of millions of dollars and penetrates every part of society, including the civil administration and security authorities. Much of the violence, including a recent bomb outside a bar, is likely to be connected to business disputes. No one knows exactly who looted a huge amount of explosive from a quarry or stole 380 automatic weapons from a barracks earlier this year. But the means for massive violence are clearly available. 

Locally, mosquito coils are used as fuses for bombs. Currently in southern Thailand, no one knows how long there is left to burn.

 

 

Back to Part 36

 

 
 

End of extra text.

  Homepage         Disclaimer to these pages        Part XXXV        Part XXXVI      Index to birth of Kweb

 

 

 

 

_____________________________________________________________